ICYMI: Groundwork Details Amazon’s “Decoy Deals”; Calls for Congress/FTC to Act on Press Call

November 16, 2026

ICYMI: Groundwork Details Amazon’s “Decoy Deals”; Calls for Congress/FTC to Act on Press Call

Pancotti: “It’s past time to hold corporations accountable for trying to pull a fast one on American families.”

Today, Groundwork Collaborative held a virtual press conference to discuss the findings of their blockbuster new investigation, Deal or Decoy? Amazon’s Deceptive Discounts, which shows that Amazon shoppers may be getting ripped off during the retail giant’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale events.

Key excerpts from the call are below.

Lindsay Owens, President and CEO:

“This is the most rigorous, intensive project that we’ve taken on in the history of the organization, and we really set out to kind of test the conventional wisdom, which is: Are the Black Friday deals really a good deal? Are the Cyber Monday deals really a good deal? We wanted to move beyond anecdotes and actually take on a rigorous and sophisticated analysis, so the team developed a study relying on historical pricing data over the last two years. Candidly, the result is pretty sobering. We find really systematic evidence of Black Friday deals not being all they’re cracked up to be.”

Breyon Williams, Chief Economist:

“Our investigation reveals that shoppers who wait for these major sale events may be playing rip-off roulette. Our report examines more than 350 products selected – not by us, but by Amazon – to be showcased as some of the best discounts of the past two years. What we found was stunning. Across these hundreds of products, nearly 1 in 3 offered no real savings. The exact same products were sold for the same price or less in the month before the sale. That includes 1 in 10 products that were actually more expensive during the ‘sale’ than they had been just a few weeks earlier.”

Elizabeth Pancotti, Vice President of Policy, Advocacy, & Research:

“It’s past time to hold corporations accountable for trying to pull a fast one on American families. It’s time for Congress to put Amazon executives in the hot seat and make them come clean about their pricing games. And the FTC should not wait to resume enforcement of its deceptive pricing guide, which has laid dormant for 50 years, and issue formal rulemaking with real teeth. We should also follow the EU’s lead and require retailers to disclose the lowest price the product has sold for in the last 30 days when an item is advertised as a sale or a deal.”

MORE ON THE REPORT: 

On the TODAY Show: “When [companies] advertise something as a discount, that should be real … These are prices that are actually higher on Black Friday than you could have gotten in the 30 days leading up to Black Friday … We are shooting for an economy in which 100% of deals are, in fact, real deals.”

In USA TODAY: “A new report from Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive thinktank, examined more than 350 Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals Amazon listed in 2024 and 2025. Nearly 1 in 3 of those deals offered no actual savings, the report found. Prices for 29% of items were the same or lower in the month leading up to Black Friday or Cyber Monday. More than half of the items had the same or lower prices in the 90 days before the sales event.”

From Ronan Farrow: “Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive think tank, took more than 350 products it says Amazon promoted as ‘deals’ during the last two Black Fridays and Cyber Mondays. It compared each deal price with the product’s lowest price on Amazon in the proceeding 30 days. By the researchers’ count, nearly 1 in 3 [deals] was no cheaper.”

In The Verge: “While our Black Friday deals suggestions focus on products that are actually discounted, a new investigation from Groundwork Collaborative examined more than 350 products showcased by Amazon on its deal pages for Black Friday and Cyber Monday in 2024 and 2025 and found that nearly one in three of them ‘offered no real savings’ and in some cases were actually sold for less in the month before the sales started.”